Stock Valuation: 3 Methods, Formulas, and Practical Examples

Daniel - Multidisciplinary Writer on Finance, Business & AI
20 Min Read

A stock’s price drops 30% in a month. Cheap, right? The answer depends on a question that often gets skipped: cheap compared with what? A falling price is not necessarily a cheap price; the business itself may simply be getting worse.

That is exactly the question stock valuation answers. Stock valuation is the process of estimating a share’s fair value from the business’s ability to generate cash for shareholders, then comparing it with the market price. This is the territory of fundamental analysis (studying the business and its financial statements), not technical analysis, which reads price charts. The result is an estimate built on assumptions, not a price forecast.

Think of it this way: suppose we are offered our favorite neighborhood meatball soup stall (a warung bakso) for Rp200 million. We would not judge the stall by the price of its pots and tables alone. We would ask: how much net profit does it make a year, how busy will it be in the future, and how big is the risk if a competitor opens at the end of the alley? Valuing a stock is basically the same, except the financial statements are thicker (and there is no smell of soup broth, hehe).

Disclaimer: Company X, Company Y, and all the figures here are dummy examples for learning purposes, not advice to buy or sell any particular stock and not personal investment recommendations.

Three Value Drivers: Cash Flow, Growth, and Risk

A stock’s fair value is driven by three things: the cash flow it generates, the growth of that cash flow, and a discount rate that reflects its risk. More cash flow raises the value, while higher risk lowers it.

Growth only adds value when the investment behind it earns an adequate return. Back to the meatball soup stall: opening a new branch only makes sense if the branch is profitable too, not just because it makes things look busier.

One important rule: cash flows must be paired with the right discount rate. Dividends and FCFE are discounted at the cost of equity (ke), while FCFF is discounted at WACC. FCFE (free cash flow to equity) is the cash available to shareholders after investment and debt payments, while FCFF (free cash flow to firm) is the cash available to all capital providers.

WACC = [E ÷ (D + E)] × ke + [D ÷ (D + E)] × kd × (1 − T)

E and D are the market values of equity and interest-bearing debt, kd is the pre-tax cost of debt, and T is the tax rate. The full explanation is in the articles on calculating WACC and the cost of equity using CAPM.

How Do We Estimate Growth?

Growth is estimated from trends in sales, margins, capital expenditure, debt, and dividend policy, then adjusted for industry conditions and competition. The raw material comes from the four types of financial statements and company financial ratios.

Historical growth is usually measured with CAGR (compound annual growth rate):

CAGR = (Ending value ÷ Beginning value)1/n − 1

Careful: n is the number of intervals, not the number of years of data. Company X’s dividend rose from Rp280 to Rp354 across six annual data points, which means five intervals. Its CAGR is about 4.80% a year. Special dividends and stock splits need to be adjusted for first.

Dividend payout ratio = Dividends per share ÷ EPS, for matching periods

Retained earnings do not automatically increase value; what matters is the quality of reinvestment. So historical figures are only a starting point.

Once the raw material is ready, there are three families of methods used most often: dividend-based, free cash flow-based, and market ratio and asset value-based. Let’s start with the most classic one.

Stock Valuation with the Dividend Growth Model

Illustration of future dividend streams as the basis of stock valuation with a dividend growth model
Future dividends need to be translated into today’s value.

The Dividend Discount Model (DDM) values a share as the sum of the present values of all dividends expected in the future. The model suits companies whose dividends reasonably reflect their ability to distribute cash.

P0 = Σt=1…∞ [Dt ÷ (1 + ke)t]

P0 is the value per share today, Dt is the dividend per share at the end of year t, and ke is the cost of equity. Wait, what if we sell the share next year? That selling price also reflects the dividends that come after, so the formula still holds. Our example, Company X, uses D0 = Rp354 and ke = 12% a year as practice assumptions.

Zero Growth: Constant Dividends

The zero growth model assumes dividends never rise, so the share’s value is simply the annual dividend divided by the cost of equity.

P0 = D ÷ ke

If the dividend stays at Rp354 forever, P0 = Rp354 ÷ 12% = Rp2,950. A market price below this figure means the stock looks undervalued according to the model, not that it is automatically a buying opportunity.

Constant Growth: The Gordon Growth Model

The Gordon Growth Model assumes dividends grow at a constant rate g forever, on the condition that g is lower than the cost of equity.

P0 = D1 ÷ (ke − g), where D1 = D0 × (1 + g) and ke > g

With g = 4.5%, D1 = Rp354 × 1.045 = Rp369.93. So P0 = Rp369.93 ÷ (12% − 4.5%) = Rp4,932.40. Growth of just 4.5% already raises the value by about 67% compared with the constant dividend model.

The catch is that this model is very sensitive. As g approaches ke, the value balloons; when g is equal or higher, the formula no longer works. The model fits mature companies best.

Variable Growth: Growth in Stages

The variable growth model splits the future into a high-growth phase and a stable-growth phase, which makes it more realistic for companies that are still expanding. Suppose Company X’s dividend grows 10% a year for three years, then 4.5% after that, with ke still at 12%.

Dummy projection for Company X; rupiah per share
YearDividendPresent value
1389.40347.68
2428.34341.47
3471.17335.37
PN = DN+1 ÷ (ke − g2)
P0 = Σt=1…N [Dt ÷ (1 + ke)t] + PN ÷ (1 + ke)N

D4 = Rp471.17 × 1.045 ≈ Rp492.38. The terminal value at the end of year three = Rp492.38 ÷ 7.5% ≈ Rp6,565.02, and its present value is Rp4,672.85. Adding the present value of the first three dividends (Rp1,024.52) brings the estimate to Rp5,697.38 per share. The year-four dividend is already inside the terminal value, so don’t count it twice.

Stock Valuation with Free Cash Flow

A company's operating cash flow allocated to investment, creditors, and shareholders in free cash flow-based stock valuation
Separate the cash for all capital providers from the cash for shareholders.

The free cash flow method values a share based on the free cash the business generates, so it still works for companies that pay no dividends. The key is to be clear about which type of free cash flow is used.

The practical measure, as Investopedia explains in its free cash flow guide, is cash flow from operations (CFO) minus capital expenditure (CapEx). However, this figure is not necessarily the same as FCFF because interest and taxes are treated differently. A cleaner formula is:

FCFF = EBIT × (1 − T) + D&A − CapEx − ΔNWC
FCFE = Net income + D&A − CapEx − ΔNWC + Net borrowing

EBIT × (1 − T) is called NOPAT (net operating profit after tax). D&A is depreciation and amortization, while ΔNWC is the increase in non-cash operating working capital, which reduces cash. Here we use the FCFF route (hehe, the jargon does pile up, but the logic is simple: cash coming in, minus what needs to be invested).

Operating value = Σt=1…N [FCFFt ÷ (1 + WACC)t] + TVN ÷ (1 + WACC)N
TVN = FCFFN × (1 + g) ÷ (WACC − g)

Dummy example for Company Y: FCFF over five consecutive years of Rp350, Rp378, Rp412, Rp447, and Rp482 billion; WACC of 10.34%; stable growth of 4% from year six. FCFF6 = Rp482 × 1.04 = Rp501.28 billion, so TV5 = Rp501.28 ÷ (10.34% − 4%) ≈ Rp7,906.62 billion. After discounting the five FCFFs and the terminal value, we get an operating value of Rp6,364.85 billion.

Common equity value = Operating value + Excess cash + Non-operating assets − Interest-bearing debt − Preferred stock − Non-controlling interests − Other claims

Assume interest-bearing debt of Rp2,250 billion, preferred stock of Rp300 billion, no excess cash or other claims, and 600 million common shares. Common equity value = Rp6,364.85 − Rp2,250 − Rp300 = Rp3,814.85 billion. Value per share = Rp3,814.85 billion ÷ 600 million shares ≈ Rp6,358.08.

It’s worth noting that interest-bearing debt is different from total liabilities; trade payables are already reflected in working capital. Banks also need a special model, because debt is effectively their raw material.

Stock Valuation with Market Ratios and Asset Values

The market ratio and asset value approach compares the share price with book value, liquidation value, or earnings per share. It is quicker to calculate, but better suited as a cross-check than as a replacement for cash flow models.

Book Value and Price to Book Value

Price to Book Value (PBV) compares the market price per share with book value of equity per share (BVPS), which is common stockholders’ equity divided by shares outstanding.

BVPS = Common stockholders’ equity ÷ Common shares outstanding; PBV = Market price ÷ BVPS

Suppose Company Y has assets of Rp4,510 billion, liabilities of Rp2,250 billion, and preferred equity of Rp300 billion. Common equity = Rp1,960 billion, so BVPS = Rp3,266.67. At a price of Rp4,125, PBV = 1.26 times.

Remember the meatball soup stall? Book value is like the price of its pots, tables, and cart: an accounting measure, not the stall’s ability to make a profit. A low PBV can mean the price is relatively cheap, but it can also signal problems with asset quality or profitability.

Liquidation Value

Liquidation value is what remains from selling all assets after deducting costs, taxes, and all senior claims, divided by the number of common shares outstanding.

If the assets sell for Rp4,300 billion, liabilities are Rp2,250 billion, preferred claims are Rp300 billion, and liquidation costs are assumed to be zero, the amount left for common stock is Rp1,750 billion, or Rp2,916.67 per share. In practice, costs and the time it takes to sell eat into this figure, so liquidation value is not a guaranteed floor.

Price Earnings Ratio and Comparable Multiples

The price earnings ratio (PER, often written P/E) compares the share price with earnings per share (EPS), showing how many times annual earnings investors are willing to pay.

PER = Market price per share ÷ EPS; Indicative value = EPS × Comparable PER

Earnings for common stockholders of Rp345 billion divided by 600 million shares gives EPS of Rp575. At a price of Rp4,125, PER = 7.17 times, which means we are paying roughly seven years of earnings up front. With a dummy comparable PER of 7.18 times, the indicative value is Rp4,128.50.

Pair historical PER with historical EPS, or forward PER with projected EPS. For loss-making companies, PER is practically useless.

Comparing the Results of the Three Stock Valuation Methods

The three stock valuation methods produce different numbers because their assumptions and perspectives differ. The table below compares the three methods by what they suit best and their example result per share.

MethodBest suited forExample result per share
DDM (Gordon and staged)Stable dividend payersRp4,932–Rp5,697
FCFF (DCF)Cash flows that can be projectedRp6,358
PBV, liquidation, PERQuick comparison and sanity checkRp2,917–Rp4,129

This wide range is actually useful: it forces us to ask which assumptions make the most sense, instead of picking the number we like best.

Checking Real Data and Testing Sensitivity

Data for valuing Indonesian listed companies is best taken from the financial and annual reports page of the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) or the company’s investor relations site, then checked for matching periods, units, and share counts after corporate actions.

For comparable ratios, use IDX statistics and pick companies with similar businesses and risks.

Sensitivity testing matters just as much. With D0 of Rp354 and g of 4.5%, the Gordon model gives about Rp5,691 at a ke of 11%, but only about Rp4,352 at a ke of 13%. A two-percentage-point difference shifts the value by more than Rp1,300 per share. Investors are not fortune tellers, so a range of values is more honest than a single number that looks precise. NYU Stern finance professor Aswath Damodaran also stresses in his introduction to valuation that uncertainty is an inseparable part of every valuation.

This article covers stage 8 of the eight stages in our financial statement analysis roadmap. If you’d like to learn in order, from the basic statements all the way to stock valuation, start with its roadmap.

Five Questions About Stock Valuation

What is stock valuation, and why does it matter to investors?

Stock valuation is an estimate of a share’s fair value based on the business’s cash flow, growth, and risk. It helps investors judge whether the market price looks expensive, fair, or cheap, so that an investment decision rests on reasoning that can be checked.

What is the difference between a stock’s fair value and its price?

A stock’s fair value is an estimate based on the company’s performance and prospects, while its price is the figure set by buying and selling on the exchange. The two can stay far apart for a long time, and fair value itself changes when the assumptions change.

How do you value a company that pays no dividends?

A company that pays no dividends can be valued with a free cash flow model, either FCFF discounted at WACC or FCFE discounted at the cost of equity. The PER and PBV of similar companies can serve as a quick comparison.

What cost of equity should be used in stock valuation?

The cost of equity in stock valuation has no single standard figure; it is usually estimated with CAPM from the risk-free rate, the stock’s beta, and the market risk premium. Because valuation results are very sensitive to this number, test several scenarios before drawing conclusions.

Does a low PER or PBV mean a stock is cheap?

A low PER or PBV does not necessarily mean a stock is cheap, because it can reflect falling earnings, weak asset quality, or deteriorating business prospects. Compare it with similar companies and check the cause in the financial statements.

Conclusion: Not a Hunt for One Magic Number

In short, no single stock valuation method is always the right one. DDM suits stable dividend payers, FCFF or FCFE suits cash flows that can be projected, and PBV, liquidation value, and PER serve as cross-checks.

Just like bargaining for the meatball soup stall, the biggest benefit of stock valuation is not finding one magic number but clarifying our reasoning: which assumptions we are using and how far the result moves if those assumptions are off. To start practicing, take the financial statements of a company whose products you know, then calculate its PER and PBV before reading anyone else’s commentary.

Of the three approaches, which one do you use most often, or which one confuses you the most? Tell us in the comments; your confusion may well be shared by other readers.

Happy calculating, and stay calm when reading prices.

This post is also available in: Indonesia

Share This Article
Multidisciplinary Writer on Finance, Business & AI
Follow:
I'm Daniel, B.Eng., MBA, born and raised in Sumatra, Indonesia, with a background in chemical engineering and a Master of Business Administration (MBA). On danieel.id, I write about finance and company analysis, the practical use of AI for learning and work, and personal notes on Islam, science, history, health, and everyday life. Health articles here are for general education, drawn from trusted sources, and are not a substitute for professional medical advice.
Leave a Comment